Employee Fraud Expert

Employee Fraud Investigation: What to Do in the First 72 Hours

This is the highest-urgency guide on our site, for employers who have just discovered suspected fraud and need immediate, practical guidance on preserving evidence and engaging experts.

Long corridor lined with rows of wooden mailboxes
Keys of a Remington adding machine
Immediate

Before You Do Anything Else

  • Do not alert the suspect
  • Do not access their computer or systems yourself
  • Do not discuss with colleagues who may warn the suspect
  • Time is critical, assets can be moved within hours
Hour 1

Hour 1, Secure the Evidence

  • Do not delete, move, or access suspect's files or emails
  • Preserve financial records in their current state
  • Note what you know and when you discovered it
  • Call a forensic accountant and civil fraud solicitor
Hours 2 to 4

Hour 2 to 4, Engage Experts

  • Instruct a forensic accountant under legal professional privilege (via your solicitor) to begin preliminary assessment
  • The forensic accountant assesses the scale of the fraud and the evidence available
  • Solicitor advises on immediate legal steps (freezing injunction, search order, POCA report)
Day 1

Day 1, Preliminary Assessment

  • Forensic accountant reviews financial records
  • Identifies the fraud type, approximate quantum, and how long it has been occurring
  • Identifies connected parties (accomplices, third parties)
  • Advises on civil vs criminal route
Days 2 to 3

Day 2 to 3, Legal Steps

  • Freezing injunction application (if assets at risk of dissipation)
  • Search order (Anton Piller) if evidence at risk
  • Norwich Pharmacal order (to identify wrongdoers)
  • Police report (if criminal proceedings appropriate)
  • Suspension of employee (following HR procedure)
Week 1 to 2

Week 1 to 2, Full Investigation

  • Forensic accountant conducts full investigation under legal professional privilege
  • Evidence-quality workpapers prepared
  • Loss quantification completed
  • Expert witness report prepared (CPR Part 35 if civil proceedings)

Civil vs Criminal, Which Route?

RouteAimOutcomeSpeed
Civil recoveryRecover moneyJudgment + asset recoveryMonths–years
Criminal prosecutionPunish offenderConviction + POCA confiscationYears
Both simultaneouslyPunish + recoverMaximum recoveryStaged
Employment tribunalDismiss + recoverET awardMonths

Preserving Legal Professional Privilege

Forensic accountants working under legal professional privilege produce reports that are protected from disclosure to the opposing party - protecting the employer's legal strategy. This requires the forensic accountant to be instructed via the solicitor, not directly by the employer. Learn more →

Need a forensic accountant for employee fraud?

Tell us about your matter and we will connect you with a qualified expert witness.